Skip to Main Content
Broadway Pizza logo topBroadway Pizza logo scroll
  • Facebook page
  • Menu
  • Drinks
  • Specials
  • Events
  • Order
  • Parties
  • Catering
  • Jobs
  • Gift Cards
  • Rewards

Our Menu

MenuCatering

Appetizers

Garlic Toast

$8.99
Freshly baked bread topped with garlic butter and toasted. | Add cheese for +$2.00. | Served with our famous meat pasta sauce for dippin’.

Cheese Curds

$10.59
Wisconsin cheese curds served with our famous meat pasta sauce.
Basket of Fries photo

Basket of Fries

$8.59
Add Eddie’s dry rub or Cajun seasoning for +$1.00 extra | Add Melted cheddar cheeseand bacon for +$2.59 extra

Chicken Strips

$10.59
Crispy and tender chicken strips. Your choice of honey mustard, BBQ sauce, or ranch.

Eddie’s Wings

Eddie’s Wings photo

Eddie’s Wings

$15.89/+
Our original, fresh seasoned wings or our breaded boneless wings tossed in your favorite handcrafted sauces and served with celery and our homemade blue cheese dressing. • Single order $15.59 | Double Wing order $27.89 | Split Double order $27.89

SAUCE:

Mild BBQ

A tame classic BBQ sauce- a favorite for all to start your night.

Eddie’s Fire BBQ

Our spicy BBQ sauce made from Eddie’s favorite hot peppers.

Hawaiian Heat

Eddie’s habañero BBQ sauce with the sweet hint of pineapple.

Basic Buffalo Sauce

This was Eddie’s secret sauce recipe to heat up his wings.

Eddie’s Buffalo Inferno

We took Eddie’s basic buffalo sauce and set it on fire with our own blend of hot habañero, cayenne, and ghost peppers.

Eddie’s Dry Rub

A flavor explosion of a house blend of dry spices.

Salads

Fresh Salads with your choice of dressings: Made from scratch Bleu Cheese, French, Ranch, Italian, Raspberry Vinaigrette, Thousand Island, Fat-Free Ranch, and Fat-Free French | Add grilled or crispy chicken for +$4.29 extra.

Bird Town Salad

$15.79
You will love this salad. Lettuce, cauliflower, bacon and parmesan cheese. Mixed in a sweet creamy dressing.
Broadway Salad photo

Broadway Salad

$15.79
Crisp lettuce, tomato, onion, green pepper, black olive, pepperoni, cucumber, croutons, and parmesan cheese. Served with garlic toast.

Caesar Salad

$15.79
Romaine lettuce tossed in creamy Caesar dressing topped with parmesan cheese and croutons.

Side Salad

$6.79
House Salad - Crisp lettuce, tomato, onion, cucumber and croutons | Caesar Salad - Romaine lettuce tossed in creamy Caesar dressing topped with parmesan cheese and croutons

BYO Pizza

BYO Pizza photo

BYO Pizza

$13.99/+
Start with a Cheese Pizza - Small $13.99| Medium $15.99 | Large $17.99

Add Your Toppings:

$2.65/+
Small $2.65 ea | Medium $2.85 ea | Large $3.15 ea • Cheese | Sausage | Pepperoni | Mushroom | Onion | Green Pepper | Black Olive | Green Olive Canadian Bacon | Bacon | Sauerkraut | Jalapeños | Banana Pepper | Shrimp | Hamburger | Anchovies | Pineapple | Chicken | Minced Garlic | Tomato

GF Pizza

$15.99
Try any Small (10”) pizza with gluten free crust for the same price as any medium.

Specialty Pizzas

No substitutions or modifications. | Our pizza is NOT made in a gluten free environment! | A pizza made on our gluten free crust should be considered reduced gluten and should not be consumed by those with celiac disease!

Eddie's Extra photo

Eddie's Extra

$18.99/+
Sausage, pepperoni, mushroom,onion, green pepper, and shrimp. • Small $18.99| Medium $21.99| Large $25.99

Broadway Special

$18.99/+
Sausage, mushroom, onion,green pepper, and shrimp. • Small $18.99| Medium $21.99| Large $25.99

Veggie Special

$18.99/+
Mushroom, onion, green pepper,green olive, and black olives. • Small $18.99 | Medium $21.99 | Large $25.99

White Special

$18.99/+
Alfredo sauce, chicken, onion,and tomato. • Small $18.99 | Medium $21.99 | Large $25.99

Buffalo Chicken

$18.99/+
Our buffalo sauce seasonedchicken, onions, and our pepperjack cheese blend. • Small $18.99 | Medium $21.99| Large $25.99
Hawaiian Special photo

Hawaiian Special

$18.99/+
Canadian bacon, seasoned chicken, pineapple. • Small $18.99| Medium $21.99 | Large $25.99

BBQ Special

$18.99/+
BBQ sauce, chicken, bacon andonion. Topped with mozzarella and cheddar cheese. • Small $18.99 | Medium $21.99 | Large $25.99

Meat Special

$18.99/+
Sausage, hamburger, pepperoni,and Canadian bacon. • Small $18.99 | Medium $21.99 | Large $25.99
Classic photo

Classic

$18.99/+
Sausage, pepperoni, mushroom,onion, and green pepper. • Small $18.99 | Medium $21.99 | Large $25.99

Eddie’s Inferno

$18.99/+
Our Eddie’s Buffalo InfernoSauce, sausage, pepperoni,Canadian bacon, jalapeños withour ghost pepper cheese blend. • Small $18.99 | Medium $21.99 | Large $25.99

Pasta

Baked Lasagna photo

Baked Lasagna

$16.79
Lasagna the way it should be. Noodles layered with our famous pasta meat sauce and melted Wisconsin mozzarella cheese. Served with garlic toast.
Fettuccine Alfredo photo

Fettuccine Alfredo

$16.79
Fettuccine noodles with alfredo sauce. Served with garlic toast. | Add grilled chicken for +$4.79
Spaghetti photo

Spaghetti

$15.79/+
Spaghetti noodles smothered in our famous spaghetti meat sauce with meatballs. Served with garlic toast. | Have it baked with cheese $16.79

Penne Rigatoni

$15.79/+
Penne rigatoni noodles covered in our famous spaghetti sauce baked. Served with a meatball and garlic toast. | Have it baked with cheese $16.79

Caboose

Wing Platter

$19.89/+
your choice of our original seasoned or boneless wings tossed in your favorite sauce with celery, homemade blue cheese and fries. | Double the Wings: $31.89

Battered Cod Platter

$17.79
Battered cod strips served with tartar sauce and your choice of fries.

Chicken Strip Platter

$19.79
Crispy and tender chicken strips served with fries and your choice of dipping sauce.

Hot Hoagies

Our hoagies are made on fresh baked bread with melted mozzarella cheese, lettuce, onions, and tomatoes smothered with our homemade hoagie sauce. Served with fries.

Club Hoagie

$15.79
With roast beef, ham & turkey.

Roast Beef Hoagie

$15.79

Turkey Hoagie

$15.79

Turkey & Bacon Hoagie

$15.79
Ham Hoagie photo

Ham Hoagie

$15.79

Veggie Hoagie

$15.79

Burgers & Sandwiches

More than great pizza, great burgers too! Our burgers and burgers & sandwiches fresh never frozen 100% Certified Angus Beef®. All of our burgers and sandwiches are served on a toasted bun with lettuce, tomato, onion and pickles with fries.

Classic Burger

$14.99
Juicy 1/2 pound patty on a freshly baked bun.

Cheeseburger

$15.99
Juicy 1/2 pound patty on a toasted bun and your choice of American, Swiss, pepper jack, cheddar or ghost pepper.

Mushroom and Swiss Burger

$16.99
Juicy 1/2 pound patty covered with sautéed onions, mushrooms, Swiss cheese.

Patty Melt

$16.99
Juicy 1/2 pound patty with melted American, pepper jack cheese, and sautéed onions. Served on marble rye bread.

Bacon Cheeseburger

$16.99
Juicy 1/2 pound patty with crispy bacon and melted American cheese.
Southwestern Burger photo

Southwestern Burger

$16.99
Juicy 1/2 pound patty with crispy bacon, Eddie’s homemade onion strings, BBQ sauce, and pepper jack cheese on a freshly baked bun.

Grilled Chicken Sandwich

$15.99
Grilled chicken breast.
Cajun Chicken Sandwich photo

Cajun Chicken Sandwich

$16.99
Chicken breast seasoned with Cajun spices and topped with pepper jack cheese, Eddie’s homemade onion strings, and chipotle mayo.

Meatball Sandwich

$15.79
Our famous meatballs and spaghetti sauce served on a freshly baked open faced hoagie bun with melted mozzarella cheese. Served with French Fries.

Kids Menu

For kids 12 and under.

7” Cheese Pizza

$8.99
Extra toppings +$1.25 each

Spaghetti with Garlic Toast

$8.99

Macaroni and Cheese with Fries

$8.99

Burger with Fries

$8.99
Add cheese for +$0.50

Chicken Strips and Fries

$8.99

Lasagna

Home made lasagna! Comes with garlic toast.

Small Lasagna

$90.00
Feeds 10 people.

Large Lasagna

$180.00
Feeds 20 people.

Spaghetti

Home made spaghetti with meat balls baked with mozzarella cheese on top. Comes with garlic toast.

Small Spaghetti

$90.00
Feeds 10 people.

Large Spaghetti

$180.00
Feeds 20 people.

Fettuccine Alfredo

Fettuccine Noodles covered in creamy Alfredo sauce. Comes with garlic toast.

Small Fettuccini photo

Small Fettuccini

$90.00
Feeds 10 people. | add $15.00 for chicken

Large Fettuccini

$180.00
Feeds 20 people. | Add +$30.00 for chicken

Penne Rigatoni

Penne Rigatoni baked with mozzarella cheese on top. Comes with garlic toast.

Small Penne Rigatoni photo

Small Penne Rigatoni

$90.00
Feeds 10 people.

Large Penne Rigatoni

$180.00
Feeds 20 people.

Wings

Wings photo

Wings

$99.00/Small
$199.00/Large
Small order has 60 wings. Large order has 120 wings. | Served with home made blue cheese or ranch dressing and celery sticks. | Flavors listed below. | Freshly seasoned wings tossed in our hand crafted sauces.

SAUCES:

Hawaiian Heat

Habanero BBQ sauce with a sweet hint of pineapple.

Mild BBQ

A tame classic BBQ sauce.

Fire BBQ

Spicy BBQ sauce made with hot peppers.

Buffalo

Secret recipe buffalo sauce.

Inferno Buffalo

Hot habanero, cayenne, and ghost pepper buffalo sauce. Extra hot.

Dry Rub

House blend of dry spices.

Traditional Salad

Crisp lettuce, tomato, onion, cucumber, and home made croutons. Variety of dressings of your choice.

Small Traditional Salad photo

Small Traditional Salad

$40.00
Feeds 10 people.

Large Traditional Salad

$80.00
Feeds 20 people.

Birdtown Salad

You will love this salad. Crisp lettuce, cauliflower, bacon, and Parmesan cheese. Tossed in a sweet creamy dressing.

Small Birdtown Salad photo

Small Birdtown Salad

$50.00
Feeds 10 people.

Large Birdtown Salad

$90.00
Feeds 20 people.

Caesar Salad

Romaine lettuce tossed in creamy Caesar dressing topped with Parmesan cheese and home made croutons.

Small Caesar Salad

$40.00
Feeds 10 people. | Add +$15.00 for chicken

Large Caesar Salad

$80.00
Feeds 20 people. | Add +$30.00 for chicken

Broadway Salad

Crisp lettuce, tomato, onion, green pepper,black olive, pepperoni, cucumber, and Parmesan cheese.

Small Broadway Salad

$50.00
Feeds 10 people.

Large Broadway Salad

$90.00
Feeds 20 people.

Pizza

Order 10+ Pizza's and receive 10% off |Order 20+ Pizza's and receive 20% off

BYO Pizza

$11.99/+
Small $11.99 | Medium $13.99 | Large $15.99 Order 10+ Pizza's and receive 10% off Order 20+ Pizza's and receive 20% off

Toppings:

$2.35/+
Small +$2.35 ea | Medium +$2.55 ea | Large +$2.95 ea • Sausage | Pepperoni | Mushroom | Onion | Green Pepper | Green Olive | Black Olive | Canadian Bacon | Bacon | Sauerkraut | Jalapenos | Banana Pepper | Shrimp | Hamburger | Anchovies | Pineapple | Chicken | Minced Garlic | Tomato

Specialty Pizza's

"No Substitutions or Modifications" • Large Order Pizza Discount 10 + = 10 % off | 20 + = 20 % off | Max discount 20%

Calssic

$16.99/+
Sausage, pepperoni, mushroom, green pepper, onion. • Small $16.99 | Medium $19.99 | Large $23.99
Meat Special photo

Meat Special

$16.99/+
Sausage, pepperoni, Canadian bacon, hamburger. • Small $16.99 | Medium $19.99 | Large $23.99

Veggie Special

$16.99/+
Mushroom, onion, green pepper, black olive, green olive. • Small $16.99 | Medium $19.99 | Large $23.99

White Special

$16.99/+
Alfredo sauce, chicken, onion, tomato. • Small $16.99 | Medium $19.99 | Large $23.99

BBQ Special

$16.99/+
BBQ sauce, chicken, bacon, onion. • Small $16.99 | Medium $19.99 | Large $23.99
Eddie's Extra Special photo

Eddie's Extra Special

$16.99/+
Sausage, pepperoni, mushroom, onion, green pepper, shrimp. • Small $16.99 | Medium $19.99 | Large $23.99

Broadway Special

$16.99/+
Sausage, pepperoni, mushroom, onion, green pepper. • Small $16.99 | Medium $19.99 | Large $23.99

Buffalo Chicken

$16.99/+
Buffalo sauce, chicken, onion. • Small $16.99 | Medium $19.99 | Large $23.99

Hawaiian Special

$16.99/+
Canadian bacon, chicken, pineapple. • Small $16.99 | Medium $19.99 | Large $23.99

Eddie's Inferno

$16.99/+
Inferno buffalo sauce, sausage, pepperoni, Canadian bacon, jalapenos topped with ghost pepper cheese. • Small $16.99 | Medium $19.99 | Large $23.99
  • Order
  • Parties
  • Catering
  • Jobs